ЁЯЗоЁЯЗ│ЁЯдЭЁЯЗ╖ЁЯЗ║ India–Russia Relations:Critical Impact on Europe
ЁЯЗоЁЯЗ│ЁЯдЭЁЯЗ╖ЁЯЗ║ India–Russia Relations:
Critical Impact on Europe
1. Energy and Sanctions Dynamics
a. India as a major buyer of Russian oil undermines European sanctions
* Since the Ukraine war, Europe drastically reduced Russian oil and gas imports.
* India simultaneously increased purchases of discounted Russian crude, refining it and selling products (diesel, jet fuel) on global markets—including indirectly into Europe.
Impact on Europe:
● Weakens the intended pressure of EU sanctions.
● Provides Russia with revenue streams that help sustain its economy and war machinery.
● Creates competitive pressure on European refiners.
b. Diversification versus dependency
● Europe’s pivot away from Russian energy increases its reliance on Middle Eastern and US energy.
● India’s stronger energy partnership with Russia makes Europe’s energy diplomacy more complex.
2. Geopolitical Balance of Power
a. India’s strategic autonomy dilutes Western attempts at isolating Russia
● India is a Quad member (with US, Japan, Australia) yet maintains close ties with Moscow.
● Europe, aligning largely with US positions, sees India’s stance as a challenge to creating a unified front against Russia.
Impact:
● Limits the global effectiveness of Western diplomatic pressure.
● Forces Europe to recalibrate its expectations of India as a like-minded democratic partner.
b. Shifting global multipolarity
● India–Russia closeness strengthens the BRICS+ narrative and challenges Western-led institutions.
● Europe faces a world where Russia is not completely isolated but embedded in alternative coalitions.
3. Defense and Security Implications
a. Indian military dependence
● on Russia ~60–70% of India’s military hardware originates from Russia.
● Ongoing cooperation in nuclear submarines, missiles (BrahMos), air defense (S-400).
Impact on Europe:
● Limits European defense exports to India because of interoperability constraints.
● India’s ties allow Russia to maintain a large defense export market despite sanctions.
● European NATO members worry about Russia indirectly benefiting from India’s payments, tech cooperation, and maintenance contracts.
b. Europe’s military-industrial competition
● France, Germany, and others are vying for India’s defense market.
● India–Russia ties slow European ambitions to become India’s main arms supplier.
4. Economic and Strategic Connectivity
a. INSTC (International North–South Transport Corridor)
Links :
India–Iran–Russia–Europe through a faster transport route.
Impact:
● Economically beneficial for Europe (faster trade) but politically sensitive due to Russia and Iran’s involvement.
● Europe must balance economic gains with geopolitical risks.
b. Eurasian connectivity vs. EU strategic autonomy
● Strong India–Russia cooperation in Eurasia reduces Europe’s influence in the region.
● EU’s vision for a “rules-based order” is challenged by alternative connectivity arrangements.
5. Diplomatic and Normative Impacts
a. India’s neutral stance on Ukraine war
● India abstained from UN resolutions condemning Russia.
● Europe interprets this as India prioritising strategic
interests over liberal democratic norms.
Impact:
● Creates tension in EU–India strategic partnership.
● Forces Europe to adopt a more pragmatic approach toward India.
b. Competition for global south leadership
● India’s ties with Russia strengthen its leadership in the Global South.
● This challenges Europe’s ability to shape narratives in developing regions.
✔️ Overall Critical Assessment
India–Russia relations create a complex strategic environment for Europe:
Negative impacts
● Undermine EU sanctions on Russia.
● Support Russian economy indirectly.
● Slow Europe’s access to India’s defense market.
● Complicate the creation of a unified anti-Russia coalition.
● Reduce Europe’s influence in Eurasia.
Positive impacts
● India provides an intermediary channel for dialogue with Russia.
● Ensures global energy market stability during Europe’s energy transition.
● Opens potential trade via new corridors like INSTC.
● Prevents Russia from becoming entirely dependent on China—beneficial for Europe in long term strategic balancing.
ЁЯзн Conclusion
India–Russia relations do not directly threaten Europe, but they significantly complicate European strategic objectives, especially regarding Russia containment, energy politics, and defense diplomacy. Europe must adapt to India’s strategic autonomy, diversify its partnerships, and engage India pragmatically instead of expecting alignment with Western positions.
Comments
Post a Comment